Specify rules in YML-File

[rruisong]

Describe the bug

We can define the rules for one type of data (i.e. osi-message) only once in yml-file. For example: If we only want to check 'SensorView.InterfaceVersion', the 'SensorView.GroundTruth.InterfaceVersion' will also be automatically checked. Because we can only define the rules for the type of data 'InterfaceVersion'

Describe how to reproduce the bug

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Get the file '20200820_example_versionTest.osi' and 'osi_version.yml' from zip-file attached.
2. Move the file '20200820_example_versionTest.osi' to folder 'data'
3. Move the file 'osi_version.yml' to folder 'requirements-osi-3'
4. Run 'osivalidator -r -requirements-osi-3 .\data\20200820_example_versionTest.osi'
5. See output

Describe the expected behavior

We supposed to check if the major version of 'SensorView' is greater than 3 and didn't mean to check the major version of 'SensorView.GroundTruth'. We would define the two different kinds of version separately.

Show some screenshots

Describe the OS you are using

• OS: Windows 10
• Language: Python
• Version 3.7

Additional context

Please get the osi- and yml-file from this zip-file.
ForOsiIssue.zip

[vkresch]

That's a good point! This should "normally" be solved by keeping the osi_version.yml as is and add rules to osi_sensorview.yml like this:

SensorView:
  version:
    version_major:
      - is_greater_than: 3

which does not generate an output at all hence there is a bug somewhere in the tree parser implementation which needs to be solved. I will take a more detailed look when I have more time. Thanks for the report!

[rruisong]

Yes, I tried this "normal" way to add the rules as well. As you mentioned, it doesn't generate the corresponding output. Thank you for the confirmation!