Skip to content

Incompatibility between Connector and SpongeNeo due to RecipeManager missing in ResourceManagerHelperImpl#sort listeners #238

@Sam-Chai

Description

@Sam-Chai

Minecraft version

1.21.1

Describe the bug

When running Connector (2.0.0-beta.8) together with SpongeNeo on Forge 1.21.1 using Forgified Fabric API, the server fails resource reloads because ResourceManagerHelperImpl#getWrapperLookup cannot find a RecipeManager in the reload listeners list. This happens because SpongeNeo’s reload listener handling changes the order and contents of the listener list before Connector/FAPI processing, so the vanilla RecipeManager is no longer present when FAPI sorts listeners.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Install connector on a SpongeNeo server
  2. Add some fabric mod such as betterend
  3. Then crashed cause the No RecipeManager found in listeners!

...

Logs

https://gist.github.com/Sam-Chai/308356f2317c3ff77194950dd3956b4f

Additional context

From the begining I found that it seems like connector caused this problem. But when I check the crash-report, I notice that this crash from the FFAPI.
The issue from connector: Sinytra/Connector#1911

Cause
ResourceManagerHelperImpl#sort(List) assumes the provided list always contains a RecipeManager instance (vanilla behavior). SpongeNeo modifies the reload process so that the RecipeManager is not in the list when FAPI’s sort runs. This triggers the IllegalStateException.

Proposed Fix
Add a compatibility patch in Connector that, when SpongeNeo is detected, ensures a RecipeManager is present in the listeners list before FAPI attempts to resolve dependencies.

Suggested Implementation
A minimal Mixin to ResourceManagerHelperImpl#sort(List) with remap=false, inserting the vanilla RecipeManager from the running server if missing:

@Inject(method = "sort(Ljava/util/List;)V", at = @At("HEAD"))
    private void connector$ensureRecipeManagerPresent(List<PreparableReloadListener> listeners, CallbackInfo ci) {
        if (!FMLEnvironment.dist.isDedicatedServer() || !ModList.get().isLoaded("spongeneo")) return;

        for (PreparableReloadListener l : listeners) if (l instanceof RecipeManager) return;

        MinecraftServer server = ServerLifecycleHooks.getCurrentServer();
        if (server == null) return;

        ReloadableServerResources res = server.getServerResources().managers();
        if (res == null) return;

        RecipeManager rm = res.getRecipeManager();
        if (rm == null) return;

        listeners.add(0, rm);
    }

This ensures that:

  • It only runs on a dedicated server.
  • It only triggers when SpongeNeo is loaded.
  • It does nothing if a RecipeManager is already in the list.
  • It adds the RecipeManager at the start of the list to preserve vanilla/FAPI expectations.

Result:
I fixed that. Connector and FFAPI with betterend running on a SpongeNeo server.

Image

But I havn't test too much, and it semms caused some tag problem and I have to fix it.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    1.21.xTargets Minecraft 1.21bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions